I think I watched the first few episodes of Sleepy Hollow before I tuned out, which was when my dad picked it up. He really liked the first season. Don't know what he thought of the second. But the article you listed was painful to get through, because even though I wasn't into it, I wanted it to do well because of its diverse cast :/.

I'll probably pick it up at some point to see what my dad liked about it, and what went wrong with the show exactly. But I can't say I'll be excited about it.