Currently without my laptop, but I'd be happy to rec you some Arrowverse icons when I get home in a couple of weeks. oh_crime should have a smattering of icons though, and is well tagged. I did a few Arrow ones from the beginning of s1 at forsquares, and there's a few Supergirl ones at spankulert.

Hi btw! I moseyed over here from ladybusiness :)

Strange that such a big thing as Arrowverse has no community on dw... *misses the olden days*